Thread:Yukine14/@comment-29818919-20161124160751/@comment-26175537-20161125221032

There is a complete difference between her stating that Ja'far is her SON and that she see's people as her CHILDREN.

You couldn't be more wrong. Let me rephrase this with the exact same meaning.

" There is a complete difference between her stating that Ja'far is her CHILD and that she see's people as her CHILDREN.''

The information is also not right. Rurumu also said directly to Serendine that she is her daughter too. Then why only add it to Ja'far's page? If you insist on keeping the information, then I'd like you to add the adoptive info to Serendine and other people of the Trading Company too.

Yes, she is like a mother figure to Ja'far, I agree fully. But I don't think it's safe to put it as adoption. Stating that Rurumu is like a mother to Ja'far is fine, but not that she and Hinahoho adopted him. Ja'far doesn't seem to consider either as an actual mother or father. He calls Rurumu miss which doesn't seem like something you'd call your adoptive mother, and he barely interacts with Hinahoho. Especially in the main series, he has no interaction with him, but if Ja'far considers Hinahoho his father, why wouldn't he say a word to him? Also, saying that Ja'far has a little brother doesn't directly mean that he's adopted into the family. It's meant visually. In Japan (I know the setting isn't Japanese, but anime itself is) people easily consider each other family, but there's no speaking of actual adoption.

Also, it's speculation information. There is no official statement of Ja'far being Rurumu and Hinahoho's adoptive child. Just as there isn't official confirmation of Ja'far being Sinbad's right hand. Ja'far himself said he is Sin's right hand, and he knows his schedule. He even plans his schedule. I know this is speculation from mere words too, but why should this not be allowed on the page, while the adoption is allowed? It's equally vague. No one in the manga spoke of adoption. Neither Rurumu, Hinahoho or anyone else mentioned the word adoption, so the information is even more vague than my Ja'far information.

PS: I still think that Taka agrees with me, as they said that we both took wordings too literally.